AskPrice
Covergirl Professional All In One Mascara

Covergirl Professional All In One Mascara

Prices as of September 26, 2026, as listed by each retailer — verify the current price on the retailer's site before purchase.

Price history tracked at JCPenney price tracker

14-day low
$6.79
Sep 17 · JCPenney
Best price
$8.49
−0% vs high
14-day high
$8.49
All stores
$8$8$7
Sep 13Sep 26
  • JCPenney
Lowest in 14 days: $6.79 at JCPenney. Highest: $8.49. Current best is 0% below the 14-day high.

What buyers say

AI summary · 448 reviews

Many buyers love this mascara for its natural look and easy removal, but a significant share report it now flakes, smudges, or causes eye irritation due to formula changes. It remains a top choice for sensitive eyes despite growing concerns.

Liked

  • Natural, non-clumpy finish
  • Easy soap-and-water removal
  • Long-lasting without smudging

Complaints

  • Flakes and smudges by midday
  • Causes red, itchy, swollen eyes
  • Contains phenoxyethanol and missing ingredients
  • Formula changed—no longer effective

Generated by AI from real customer reviews at JCPenney — may miss nuance. Summarized Sep 2026.

About this product

COVERGIRL Professional All In One Mascara is a gel-formula mascara designed for sensitive eyes, featuring a hypoallergenic formula that helps avoid clumping and blobs. Its precision brush enhances lashes for a fuller, more defined look without irritation. Suitable for everyday use on the face, this product is made in the US.

  • hypoallergenic formula
  • gel formulation
  • for sensitive eyes
  • clump-free application
  • made in US

Based on 448 reviews at JCPenney

Read all 448 reviews on JCPenney

AskPrice does not host review text. We aggregate the public rating from the retailer and link to the source for full reviews.

You might also like

More from COVERGIRL

All 33 COVERGIRL products →
Covergirl Professional All In One Mascara — Price History