AskPrice
Newman Penny Loafer

Newman Penny Loafer

Prices as of September 26, 2026, as listed by each retailer — verify the current price on the retailer's site before purchase.

Price history tracked at Nordstrom Rack price tracker

14-day low
$157.97
Sep 13 · Nordstrom Rack
Best price
$157.97
−0% vs high
14-day high
$157.97
All stores
$158$158$158
Sep 13Sep 26
  • Nordstrom Rack
Lowest in 14 days: $157.97 at Nordstrom Rack. Highest: $157.97. Current best is 0% below the 14-day high.

What buyers say

AI summary · 135 reviews

Many buyers appreciate the classic style and durable craftsmanship of the Newman Penny Loafer, but a significant share find them uncomfortably stiff and poorly fitting, especially for wider feet. The glossy finish on some colors is also a recurring point of disappointment.

FitRuns large

Liked

  • Classic timeless design
  • Excellent leather quality
  • Versatile styling

Complaints

  • Extremely stiff leather
  • Glossy, unnatural finish
  • Holes and manufacturing defects

Generated by AI from real customer reviews at Nordstrom Rack — may miss nuance. Summarized Sep 2026.

About this product

Allen Edmonds Newman Penny Loafer is a leather dress shoe featuring a traditional penny loafer design with an antique finish. The shoe has a non-removable cushioned insole with arch support for added comfort, and it is constructed with a leather upper, lining, and sole with a rubber heel. This style blends timeless elegance with functional support, suitable for both professional and casual settings.

  • Leather upper and lining
  • Cushioned insole with arch support
  • Rubber heel for durability
  • Antique finish
  • Non-removable insole
  • Imported construction

Based on 135 reviews at Nordstrom Rack

Read all 135 reviews on Nordstrom Rack

AskPrice does not host review text. We aggregate the public rating from the retailer and link to the source for full reviews.

You might also like

More from Allen Edmonds

All 198 Allen Edmonds products →
Newman Penny Loafer — Price Tracker & History