AskPrice
21811912.fpx

Men's McGuffey Plain Toe Shoes

Available at 2 stores

Best price · Macy's $119.90

Prices as of September 25, 2026, as listed by each retailer — verify the current price on the retailer's site before purchase.

Price history tracked at Macy's price trackerNordstrom price tracker

14-day low
$119.90
Sep 12 · Macy's
Best price
$119.90
−0% vs high
14-day high
$119.99
All stores
$120$120$120
Sep 12Sep 25
  • Nordstrom
  • Macy's
Lowest in 14 days: $119.90 at Macy's. Highest: $119.90. Current best is 0% below the 14-day high.

What buyers say

AI summary · 499 reviews

A stylish, comfortable dress shoe with a classic look that many buyers appreciate, though some report recurring issues with sole separation and squeaking. The quality has declined for a minority of users, but overall satisfaction remains high.

FitRuns small

Liked

  • Classic, versatile design
  • Excellent leather quality

Complaints

  • Sole separates from upper
  • Shoes squeak on hard floors
  • Laces fray quickly
  • Color does not match description

Generated by AI from real customer reviews at Macy's — may miss nuance. Summarized Sep 2026.

About this product

Johnston & Murphy Men's McGuffey Plain Toe Shoes are a classic dress shoe designed for comfort and style, featuring a lightweight Strobel construction and a supple oiled full-grain leather or soft matte nubuck upper with breathable knit accents. The shoes include a leather performance fabric-covered cushioned insole and a skeletal leather lining for added durability and breathability. They are available in medium and wide widths, with updated textures and styles for modern appeal. Spot clean only. Imported.

  • full-grain leather upper
  • lightweight Strobel construction
  • cushioned insole
  • breathable knit accents
  • spot clean only
  • available in medium and wide

Based on 499 reviews at Macy's

Read all 499 reviews on Macy's

AskPrice does not host review text. We aggregate the public rating from the retailer and link to the source for full reviews.

You might also like

More from Johnston & Murphy

All 1,053 Johnston & Murphy products →
Men's McGuffey Plain Toe Shoes — Compare Prices at 2 Stores