puma
Speedcat OG Sneaker
↓ $100.00 · store discount-60%
from$40.00
Men's McGuffey Slip On Shoes
Available at 2 stores
Prices as of September 26, 2026, as listed by each retailer — verify the current price on the retailer's site before purchase.
Price history tracked at Nordstrom price trackerMacy's price tracker
14-day low
$99.90$99.90
Sep 13 · NordstromSep 13 on Nordstrom
Best price
$99.90$99.90
−17% vs high17% below 14-day high
14-day high
$119.90$119.90
All storesAcross all tracked stores
$120$110$100
Sep 13Sep 26
- Nordstrom
- Macy's
What buyers say
AI summary · 417 reviews
A stylish, comfortable slip-on with excellent arch support and a sleek look that many buyers love for daily wear. Some buyers note quality issues like squeaking, poor durability, and inconsistent leather quality, though these are a minority.
FitRuns large
Liked
- Excellent arch support
- Comfortable right out of the box
- Stylish and versatile design
Complaints
- Squeaks on hard floors
- Poor durability and early wear
- Inconsistent leather quality
Generated by AI from real customer reviews at Macy's — may miss nuance. Summarized Sep 2026.
About this product
Johnston & Murphy Men's McGuffey Slip On Shoes are casual leather dress shoes featuring a skeletal leather lining for a soft, unconstructed feel. The cushioned insole with a genuine leather dis-infectant performance-mesh cover enhances comfort, while stretch gores allow for easy on-and-off. Made with full grain leather uppers and rubber soles, these slip-ons offer durable construction and a modern update to classic styling.
- Full grain leather upper
- Cushioned insole with mesh cover
- Stretch gores for easy wear
- Rubber sole for durability
- Skeletal leather lining
- Spot clean only
Based on 417 reviews at Macy's
Read all 417 reviews on Macy'sAskPrice does not host review text. We aggregate the public rating from the retailer and link to the source for full reviews.
You might also like
vance co
William Tru Comfort Plain Toe Derby
↓ $129.99 · store discount-62%
from$49.97
stacy adams
Stacy Adams Everidge Mens Round Closed Toe Slip-On Shoe
↓ $130.00 · store discount-60%
$51.99
marc joseph new york
Baker St. Derby
↓ $175.00 · store discount-83%
from$29.98
converse
Chuck Taylor® All Star® Low Top Sneaker
↓ $60.00 · store discount-42%
$34.97
nunn bush
City Walk EZ Slip-On Sneaker - Wide Width Available
↓ $85.00 · store discount-65%
$29.97
More from Johnston & Murphy
All 1,054 Johnston & Murphy products →
johnston & murphy
Amherst 2.0 U-Throat Leather Sneaker
$139.00
johnston & murphy
Men's Amherst 2.0 Knit Plain Toe Sneakers
↓ $139.00 · store discount-25%
$104.25
johnston & murphy
Upton GL3 Luxe Hybrid Waterproof Golf Shoe
↓ $169.00 · store discount-53%
$79.97
johnston & murphy
Men's Upton Cap Toe Shoe
↓ $169.00 · store discount-30%
$118.30
johnston & murphy
Anders Sneaker
$165.00
johnston & murphy
Men's Harrison Bit Round Toe Loafers
↓ $175.00 · store discount-25%
from$131.25