Image courtesy of Macy's
Better Than Sex Foreplay Mascara Primer
Available at 4 stores4.4 from 581 reviews
Compare prices
4 stores · same UPC · as of Oct 28, 2026- NordstromIn stockfrom $16.00
- Macy'sCheck availability$30.00
- JCPenneyBest priceIn stock$30.00
- Kohl'sIn stock$30.00
Prices as listed by each retailer. Check the retailer's site before you buy.
In this group
5 listingsPrice history
Last 14 days across 4 stores- Nordstrom
- Macy's
- JCPenney
- Kohl's
Lowest recorded: $17.00 at JCPenney on Oct 28, 2026 · tracked since Sep 16, 2026.
What buyers say
- Macy's581 reviewsRead ↗
1% of buyers would recommend it.
What buyers like
- Strong curl hold
- Significant volume and length
- Works well with Better Than Sex mascara
Common complaints
- Extremely hard to remove
- Clumpy application
- Feels sticky and heavy
Based on 581 reviews from Macy's. AskPrice doesn't host review text — read the full reviews at each store.
About this product
Too Faced Better Than Sex Foreplay Mascara Primer is a waterproof, nourishing lash primer designed to lengthen, thicken, and lift eyelashes while improving mascara wear for up to 24 hours. Its deep black pigment and double-arch molded crescent brush coat each lash from root to tip, separating and defining strands. Formulated with argan and grape seed oils, it supports lash health and is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. The lightweight liquid formula dries quickly and can be worn alone or under mascara for enhanced volume and curl.
- Waterproof formula
- Deep black pigments
- Infused with argan and grape seed oils
- Double-arch molded crescent brush
- Up to 24-hour improved mascara wear
- Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lenses
Details
- Brand
- Too Faced
- Category
- Eyes
- Color
- Pitch Black
- Sizes
- Standard
- Material
- liquid
- Care
- Remove with a cotton pad and waterproof makeup remover
- Updated
- 7 days ago
Track this at each store
Price adjustment windows: if the price drops soon after you buy.You might also like
$26.00too faced · Better Than Sex Waterproof Liquid Eyelinerin 5 stores
$16.00too faced · Too Faced Mini Better Than Sex Volumizing Mascarain 9 stores
$29.00too faced · Born This Way Mini Eyeshadow Palettein 6 stores
from $16.00anastasia beverly hills · Brow Freeze® Gelin 5 stores
$16.00too faced · Travel-Size Ribbon Wrapped Lash Tubing Mascarain 7 stores
More from Too Faced
All Too Faced products ›
$22.00too faced · Kissing Jelly Lip Oil Glossin 5 stores
$29.00too faced · Born This Way Mini Eyeshadow Palettein 6 stores
$26.00too faced · Better Than Sex Waterproof Liquid Eyelinerin 5 stores
$16.00too faced · Travel Size Born This Way Super Coverage Multi-Use Longwear Concealerin 7 stores
from $16.00too faced · Too Faced Ribbon Wrapped Lash Extreme Length Tubing Mascarain 7 stores
Not quite the right set?
Search every store at once and compare their prices.